- 5/19/2013 Shepard designs dream room
- 5/19/2013 Sue Jolly Award will honor student Mock Trial Team member
- 5/19/2013 Anglican Church to host homeless meeting
- 5/19/2013 North Augusta bookings
- 5/19/2013 Suspect sought in theft of Walmart cell phones
- 5/19/2013 STEMfest exposes students to principles of science, technology
- 5/19/2013 North Augusta crime blotter
- 5/19/2013 North Augusta High School hosts 309 student runners
- 5/19/2013 Predators fall to Knights in walk-off fashion
- 5/12/2013 Predators stumble against Knights, face uphill battle
- 5/12/2013 Lady Predators have to win to stay in
- 5/12/2013 Phil Schaefer reflects on North Augusta history
- 5/12/2013 North Augusta golf team’s season ends in Sumter
- 5/12/2013 NAHS grad named SEC Men’s Golf Freshman of the Year
- 5/12/2013 World’s No. 1 disc golfer pays a visit to Hippodrome
- 5/19/2013 Column: Downtown developments: Vacations less and less important
- 5/19/2013 Wrinkles: Recognizing mothers and angels
- 5/19/2013 Phragments from Phyllis: A mother’s a mother for the rest of her life
- 5/19/2013 Letter: Bring the troops home from Afghanistan
- 5/19/2013 Column: New PASS exams intended to benefit student performance
- 5/19/2013 Chaplain's corner: In his hand
- 5/12/2013 Column: The best of both borders
- 5/12/2013 Chaplain’s Corner: A mother’s joy
- 5/12/2013 Downtown developments: Bad customer service, part two
- 5/12/2013 Letter: Riverkeeper is a benefit to North Augustans
Mistrial declared in Cartwright case
A lone juror left 12 hopelessly deadlocked and mistrial was declared in the trial of a Trenton man accused of 28 sex crimes against victims as young as 4.
After two days of testimony and one of deliberation, the foreman of the 12-person panel was the only one who did not believe that Harold B. Cartwright III was guilty beyond a reasonable doubt of all counts of criminal sexual conduct with a minor and committing a lewd act upon a minor.
Testimony at trial framed Cartwright as a predator who sexually abused three girls over the course of more than 20 years. The alleged attacks were against the girls when one was as young as 4 years old.
Cartwright professed that the charges were fabricated as revenge for his finding pornographic pictures on the Internet featuring one of the alleged victims. She, however, said it was not her in the pair of pictures. An Aiken County Sheriff's Office investigator also testified that it was not the victim in the pictures.
As the case did not end with a verdict, it can be prosecuted again.
Second Circuit Solicitor J. Strom Thurmond Jr. said that his office would need to evaluate; but as of Thursday afternoon, they said they will look to bring the case again. Cartwright had been in Aiken County detention center since his 2011 arrest. He will remain incarcerated until a future jury reaches a verdict, the charges are dropped or a bond is set by a Circuit Court Judge.
The juror who was not convinced by the evidence said it was a "he said, she said," case and that he found neither the defendant nor the alleged victims credible. He added that the DNA evidence, where semen matching the defendant was found on one victim's bedsheets, "did not prove anything" as "it could have come from anywhere."
An expert in forensic DNA analysis from the S.C. State Law Enforcement Division testified that there was a 1 in 16 trillion chance of the semen sample not being from Cartwright.
Speaking outside, a male juror initially had no comment and walked away. However, he then spun around and exclaimed, "That bastard was guilty! And you can print that."
Several members of the jury expressed anger and frustration at the foreman's view of the case. Two or three made efforts to apologize to the victims.
"I believe everything you said in there, I am so sorry for this," a female juror, who also did not wish to be named, said to one victim and her family. "I am just sorry."
Outside of the courtroom, the victims and their families were distraught. Many were sobbing, wandering around the parking lot and onto the adjacent Park Avenue.